As children become conventional readers, teachers rely on various forms of assessment to differentiate instruction for their students. A commonly used assessment tool is a running record which is used to closely observe and record children’s oral reading behaviors and plan instruction (Morrow, 2009). Running records give teachers the opportunity to observe what strategies students are using while reading.
I administered a running record assessment to D.O., a first grader EL at Patterson International Elementary. D.O. read a cold DRA level 12 book, a text he had never seen before, for the running record assessment. Based on an accuracy rate of 90%, this level book is considered instructional for D.O. While the text is at instructional level for D.O., he only self-corrected one time despite making 10 errors. D.O. used visual cues in nearly all of his errors. He replaced a word with another word that looked similar. For example, he replaced ‘thud’ with ‘thump’ and ‘fast’ with ‘fat’. The replacement in the first example did not affect the meaning of the sentence however, his comprehension could certainly be affected by additional errors like the second example where the replacement makes no sense in the context of the story. For all of D.O.’s visual cue errors, the first two or three letters/sounds of the replacement word matched the word in the text. In my opinion as his reading teacher, these behaviors indicate that D.O. is not self-monitoring for understanding or, self-correcting while he is reading. Since this was an assessment from a cold text, he was focused mostly on using visual cues to decode and understanding what he was reading, was secondary.
In addition to using visual cues to read, D.O. also utilized syntax cues to correct errors in his reading. D.O. is an English Language Learner and frequently when E.L.L.s speak or read, they leave ending sounds off of words and this makes their speech grammatically incorrect. It is encouraging that D.O. made syntax errors because it shows that he understands the structure of the English language. Although many of his syntax errors affect the meaning of the story, the fact that they are grammatically correct demonstrates his progress as an English Language Learner. Likewise, D.O.’s meaning cue errors also indicate a deeper understanding of the English language and vocabulary. For example, the text was written as “The bus turned onto a big road.” and D.O. read “The bus drives onto a big road.” In replacing “turned” with “drives”, D.O. shows that he understands the meaning of the text.
Many of D.O.’s errors are based on visual cues and these have the greatest impact on his comprehension of the text. There are several instructional recommendations designed to teach him self-monitoring techniques that would help him look at the entire word and, make sure the sounds in the word he is saying match the sounds in the text. One technique would be to use Elkonin boxes to ensure that he is correctly identifying the phonemes in a word and blending them correctly. He could then apply this technique to unknown words, ensuring that he is reading all letters and recoding them accurately. Other techniques would be to have him practice echo reading with a teacher and practice one-to-one correspondence. As D.O. follows along with the text he will hear accurate reading being modeled and should be able to reproduce that accurate reading. It is important in this technique, to make sure that while he is reading D.O. slides his finger under each letter as he says it so that he does not omit or replace a sound. By segmenting and recoding words accurately and utilizing echo reading, D.O. would improve his accuracy and self-correction rate.
Miscue analysis give teachers insights that influence their planning. Personalizing instruction helps children become fluent, accurate readers who can focus on comprehension techniques instead of using meaning, visual and syntax cues to decode.
Reference
Morrow, L.M. (2009). Literacy development in the early years: Helping children read and write (6th ed.). Boston : Pearson Education, Inc.
I learned a lot from this observation. Your summary was very helpful for the running record I gave my Ell student, this past week. I was more focused on the deletion of ending sounds. Becuause of your comment, I was able to put some tools in place prior and after the read to help boost his recognition of ending sounds as well as his abitlity to comprehend the text.
ReplyDeleteYour summary also prompted me to put some strategies in place throughout my day to help my ELL student and my other student.