Learning Acquisition
Memorize sight words and string together those words to make meaning | Use background knowledge, graphophonics, syntax and semantics to understand and create meaning |
Apply knowledge of phonics to reading to recode and memorize sight words that do not follow phonics rules | Uses graphophonics, syntax and semantics as cueing systems to understand the meaning of the text |
Break words into known phonetic parts to help learn them. | Uses prefixes, suffixes, and root words to construct the meaning of the unknown word |
Teach tricky words and vocabulary out of context/before reading so that when ELs encounter those words they already know them | Learns vocabulary by using context |
Reads orally, chorally or in round-robin style so the teacher can help ELs with words they don’t know | Reads silently and uses context clues and other strategies to figure out the meaning of the text. Importance of constructing meaning from the entire text and not from each individual word |
Importance on the product- good piece of writing | Stresses developing their own writing process which will assist in producing good writing |
Part + part + part…building up to the whole piece | Begin with idea and teach the pieces that would help develop that idea |
Direct, explicit instruction on letter, word, sentence, paragraph formation | Creates a safe environment that will help produce authentic writing as a form of self-expression |
CONVENTIONS!!!! | Emphasis on ideas rather than conventions. Conventions should be taught within a context, not just alone |
Heavy teacher influence on writing-teacher corrects each piece | Peers and teachers take an active role in the revision and editing process |
Teacher teaches language components directly and corrects when necessary | Make language comprehensible i+1 |
Drill and kill to practice language | Use language in everyday setting to help communicate with peers |
Correction of errors to ensure they don’t become habit | Errors are ok- focus on the meaning of the message and expressing ideas. Model correct grammar and language use. |
Proponent-B.F. Skinner | Proponents-Chomsky and Krashen |
Students are aware of what they are learning | Subconscious: not aware of the language acquisition |
Happens in school-study rules and grammar | Can occur anywhere as long as ELs are receiving messages that are comprehensible |
Freeman, D. & Freeman Y. (2004). Essential linguistics: What you need to know to teach. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
I like the chart. How do you create this in a blog?
ReplyDeleteI like that you can run down the list and easily make comparisions between the two.
A great organizer that differentiates the learning and acquisition views. I like the way you interpreted the differences in a way that is easy to read and easy to remember. Can I print this? Hmm - it would be very useful to have. I was able to read it and glean new information from what I had read in the text. Thanks for your expertise and insight.
ReplyDelete