My classroom environment as a growing writer was very similar to those outlined by best practices, although some of my teachers had different approaches to creating a quiet, peaceful environment for writing. I remember my fourth grade teacher, Mr. Helfrich, playing classical music, or sometimes The Grateful Dead, softly as we wrote in our journals. I felt comfortable and clam as I wrote along with the music. On the other hand, my second grade teacher, demanded silence during writing time and we would lose recess if we talked. I felt tense and scared during writing, which inhibited my growth as a writer.
As a student I always felt like writing topics were dictated by my teachers and curriculum and lacked choice. I was never really passionate about writing until I was in high school and had the choice to write about something that interested me. When I was a junior in high school I got to write a historical fiction narrative from the point of view of a soldier in the American Civil war. It was the first time that I was really excited about writing. I had always been interested in history and was able to explore story telling through a lens that I felt passionate about. I spent the most amount of time I had ever spent on that paper and was gratified when I received an ‘A’. Although I was not given free reign of what I wanted to write about, the power of writing about an interest sparked a love of writing within me.
Overall, I think that my writing instruction was closer to an acquisition view/process writing classroom. The reason I believe this is because I do not remember being explicitly taught how to write, I just know that I know how to write now, which is in opposition to the learning view. "From a learning point of view, writing, like reading, must be taught directly. From an acquisition perspective, writing, like speaking, is a form of output that reflects the language competence an individual as acquired"(Freeman & Freeman, 2004, p. 29). I do think that my experiences reflect a slight change in thinking because there are some traditional writing classroom influences, like all students writing on the same topic, but the majority of my writing instruction was more processed based. I believe that in today's classrooms, there does need to be a balance between the two opposing view points. I try to create authentic writing conditions but I do also have the final edit on all my students papers.
Resources
Resources
Freeman, D.E. & Y.S. Freeman. (2004). Essential linguistics: What you need to know to teach. Portsmouth , NH : Heinemann.
I think many of our children in our own classrooms feel the way you did at the beginning. They feel frustrated and compare themselves to others around them. I love that you wrote about the environment in your two very different classrooms as well. I feel this is so important in a classroom. In my own classroom, we turn the lights down and listen to classical music. I hope my children feel the same positive way you did in your 4th grade classroom. I also think that we are stuck in the no choice realm at times in our classrooms, but it is up to us to change that with our chidlren! Great blog!
ReplyDeleteThe way in which you described the contrasting classroom environments was powerful. It is amazing to think about how teacher's tone and expectation can so strongly affect the student's emotional state, process, and product of writing. I can remember a 3rd grade teacher with a terrifying reputation. When in her classroom for math each day, I was scared straight! Panic rushed over me when she called attention to a friend and me talking. It is sad when teachers feel some weird power from intimidating their students. Teachers' real power is in helping students to discover their passions and create a love of learning.
ReplyDeleteYour first paragraph sounds like a classroom too heavily based on acquisition methods- you just wanted some guidance! We sometimes get so carried away with providing "authentic writing" for our students that we forget that. I think you hit the nail on the head in your last paragraph-finding a balance. Both views are "best practice" when they are carried out to meet the needs of your students. It sounds like that is exactly what you do with yours!
ReplyDeleteIt's amazing what we remember from our own classroom experience and the things that stand out. I was that second grade teacher who thought in order for the students to write it had to be silence. How awful for my students! However, when I started reading books on writing and learning new things about the writing environment I realized that writing is about talking and collaborating. It's refreshing to read about a personal experience and be able to relate it to my own teaching.
ReplyDelete